Appendix I: MRC checklist: quantitative research

The MRC Ethics Committee wishes to process applications for clearance as speedily as possible. To help us do this applicants need to provide a clear and comprehensive protocol for assessment.

Please note that all applications will be checked for completeness by the administration before submission to the Committee. All incomplete proposals will be returned to the applicant for updating which could result in unfortunate delays in the review process.

Below is a checklist to help achieve this. 
Please print, complete and attach the checklist to your submission

Yes

No

1

Is the application labelled?
Give project title, National Programme.

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

             

2

Are details of the investigators provided?
Name, title, FULL mailing address, telephone and fax numbers, e-mail address of principal investigator and co-investigators from each collaborating organisation.

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

                 

3

Have key words been given?   
Up to 6 scientific descriptors (key words) for the project.

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

           

4

Is the following declaration provided, dated and signed?
I, - name of principal investigator- have read the MRC Guidelines on Ethics for Medical Research and have prepared this proposal with due cognisance of its content. Furthermore I will adhere to the principles expressed when conducting this proposed research project.

Did you have any difficulty with any specific provision in the guidelines concerning your proposal?   If so, please provide details - this will be very helpful to the MRC Ethics Committee.

___________________________________________________

___________________________________________________

___________________________________________________

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

Please give a statement of the research problem.

___________________________________________________

      

5

Has the application been approved by a project review committee?
If YES, which one?

___________________________________________________

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

             

6

Has the application been checked for content, grammar and spelling?
If yes, by whom?

___________________________________________________

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

                       

7

Are the copies of the following attached?[N/A = not applicable]

  • An Executive Summary, stating the AIM, METHODS, OUTCOME and INTENDED FEEDBACK of the study.

Yes

Yes/No box

N/A

Yes/No box

  • Subject information sheet

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

  • Informed consent form

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

Are the technical terms in the above forms explained in lay terms?

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

  • Translations into languages relevant to the study area.  If yes, which language(s)?


___________________________________________________
            

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

If consent will be verbal or informed consent is not necessary, please explain why not

___________________________________________________

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

           

8

Is any questionnaire to be used provided?

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

            

9

Is confidentiality clarified?

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

                 

10  

Has consent from minors been explained?
If subjects are under age (less than 14 years for treatment or 18 years for an operation) from whom will consent be obtained, e.g. parent, guardian, etc.?

___________________________________________________

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

                    

11

Has blood sampling been clarified?
Venous or arterial, the amount and frequency and by whom?

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

                 

12

Has any drugs administration been specified?
If yes, have the drug, dose, frequency, and who will administer it been clarified?

Yes/No box
Yes/No box

Yes/No box
Yes/No box

                      

13

Have drug side-effects been specified?

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

                  

Yes

No

14

Have the following protocol details been provided?

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

           

Table of Contents

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

Number the pages in the proposal and include page numbers in the contents.

                   

Methodology details

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

1

Overall aim and specific objectives.

2

Background and rationale: This must be substantial and include references to or details of similar studies, and allow for thorough technical peer review by experts in your field.

3

Technical work plan: Describe in considerable detail your overall experimental design, methods and research protocols. Discuss research alternatives if your original assumptions/hypotheses prove incorrect.

4

Statistical planning: Has there been consultation with a statistician? If NO, please provide reasons. If YES, please give details including randomisation, sample size and proposed methods of analysis.

5

Time chart: Critical path analysis identifying when each activity is to take place. Identify points at which timing is critical (e.g. a season when a particular field study would need to be done).

6

References cited.

7

Description of methods applied.

8

Has this study been approved by the research group you operate in, or by any other peer group, for scientific validity? 

If yes, name the group. ___________________________________________________

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

                     

Management details

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

1

Management approach: Discuss the overall management of the project. Where is managerial responsibility? Consider specific functions such as reporting, financial management, procurement of equipment and research supplies, and management of field activities.

2

Staff and scientific collaboration: Who will do what, when and where? (one page).

3

Facilities: Describe the facilities and resources available for the proposed research.

                       

Budget details

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

1

Budget: full detailed budget for each year. The following headings can act as a guide:
Salaries, equipment, its repair and maintenance, materials and supplies, training, consultation, travel, other, indirect costs/overheads.

2

Budget justification: Explain how the individual items of the budget were calculated. Justify major or unusual expenses.

3

Budget summary.

4

Has your research group reviewed and accepted the budget?

5

Do you believe the budget is fully sufficient to conduct the study ethically and scientifically?

6

Has the name of the sponsor of the study (if applicable) been indicated on the subject information sheet?

                     

Details of researchers

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

CVs and publication lists of all senior personnel involved in the project.

NOTE: Only provide qualifications and scientific experience, e.g. publications, projects, presentations.

                      

Other details

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

1

Ethical considerations: This must address all relevant ethical issues including: details of possible negative consequences to the study animals/subjects, information to be given to subjects, reporting back procedures to the community/authorities and an example of the consent form to be used.

2

Additional Review Bodies: does this protocol need to be reviewed by another institution or review board? If so, has it been submitted and what was the outcome? Please provide copies of relevant documentation.

3

Similar studies: Please list titles of any similar studies previously approved.

4

Please declare which of the following interests you may have in the study, such as:

  • resources paid directly to you or your research account;

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

  • potential financial benefits from the outcome of the study;

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

  • direct financial interest in the company;

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

  • any others;

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

  • any gains to your family;

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

  • travel sponsorship.

Yes/No box

Yes/No box

5

Name the possible (both positive and negative) short- and long-term consequences of the study.

 

Last updated:
09-Feb-2006

Module administrator:
adri.labuschagne@mrc.ac.za

Technical enquiries:
Webmaster

Copyright © 1999-current
SAHealthInfo TM

To SAHealthInfo home